Grants are funds awarded for a very specific purpose or project, with strict restrictions on how they can be used, while donations are often unrestricted gifts given to support an organization’s general mission or a broad cause. Grants require a detailed proposal and application, and the recipient must adhere to the grantor’s specific terms, whereas donations are simpler gifts, often from individuals, with fewer conditions.
Grants differ from other types of donations in several critical ways that significantly impact how nonprofits operate, plan, and manage their funding relationships.
Funding Source and Institutional Structure
Grants come from formal grantmaking institutions such as private foundations, corporate foundations, government agencies, and community foundations. These organizations have established grantmaking policies, dedicated program officers, and structured decision-making processes. Other donations typically originate from individual donors, local businesses making charitable contributions, or informal community support without institutional frameworks.
Application and Selection Process
Grant funding requires comprehensive written proposals that include project narratives, detailed budgets, organizational capacity documentation, and outcome measurements. The application process is highly competitive, with success rates often ranging from 10-30% depending on the funder. Applications undergo professional review by committees or program officers who evaluate alignment with funding priorities, organizational capacity, and potential impact.
Other donations involve much simpler processes: direct solicitation through phone calls, emails, or face-to-face meetings; online giving platforms; fundraising events; or unsolicited contributions from supporters. The “application” might be as simple as a conversation or a brief written appeal.
Purpose Specificity and Use Restrictions
Grants are almost exclusively project-specific or program-specific, with funders wanting to support particular initiatives rather than general operations. Grant agreements typically include detailed restrictions on how funds can be spent, often prohibiting their use for administrative costs, fundraising expenses, or capital improvements unless specifically approved.
Individual and corporate donations often provide more flexibility. While some donors designate gifts for specific purposes, many contributions are unrestricted, allowing nonprofits to allocate funds where most needed, including essential operational expenses like salaries, utilities, and administrative costs.
Award Amounts and Duration
Grants tend to be larger individual awards, often ranging from thousands to millions of dollars, but are typically time-limited (one to three years) and require reapplication for renewal. This creates substantial but temporary funding.
Other donations vary widely in size but are often smaller individually, though they may provide ongoing support through recurring giving programs. Individual donors might give $25 annually or $25,000, but the relationship can continue indefinitely without formal reauthorization.
Reporting and Accountability Requirements
Grant recipients must submit detailed progress reports, financial statements, and impact documentation according to specific schedules. These reports often require quantitative data, narrative descriptions of activities, and analysis of outcomes against stated objectives. Some grants include site visits or additional monitoring requirements.
Other donations typically require only basic acknowledgment, tax receipts, and perhaps inclusion in annual reports. The accountability is more informal and relationship-based rather than contractually mandated.
Relationship Dynamics and Stewardship
Grant relationships are primarily institutional and professional, focusing on programmatic results, organizational capacity, and measurable impact. Communication tends to be formal, scheduled, and outcome-oriented.
Donor relationships are more personal and emotional, emphasizing connection to the mission, recognition of contribution, and ongoing engagement. Stewardship involves thank-you notes, donor events, newsletters, and personal updates about impact.
Timing and Predictability
Many grants follow annual or biennial funding cycles with predictable application deadlines, review periods, and award announcements. This allows for strategic planning but requires long lead times between application and funding.
Individual donations can be solicited and received throughout the year, providing more immediate funding opportunities but less predictable revenue streams.
Capacity Requirements
Securing grants requires specialized organizational capacity including grant writers, program managers capable of designing measurable projects, and administrative systems for tracking outcomes and managing compliance. Smaller organizations may struggle to meet these requirements.
Cultivating individual donors requires different skills: relationship building, storytelling, event management, and donor database management. These skills are often more accessible to organizations of all sizes.
Strategic Funding Implications
These differences create distinct strategic considerations. Grant funding can provide substantial resources for specific initiatives but may leave organizations with “funding gaps” for essential operations. The competitive nature and specific requirements mean organizations must invest significant time and expertise in pursuit of uncertain outcomes.
Individual donations, while often smaller, can provide the flexible funding necessary for organizational stability and growth. They also create a broader base of community support that can be valuable for organizational sustainability and advocacy efforts.
Risk and Sustainability Factors
Heavy reliance on grants creates vulnerabilities when funding priorities change, programs end, or economic conditions affect grantmaking. The restricted nature of grants can also create challenges in maintaining organizational infrastructure.
Diversified individual donor bases provide more stability and flexibility, though they require ongoing cultivation and may be affected by economic downturns or changing donor priorities.
Understanding these fundamental differences enables nonprofit leaders to develop appropriate strategies for each funding type, allocate staff resources effectively, and build sustainable funding portfolios that balance the substantial but restricted nature of grants with the flexibility and community engagement of individual donations. The most successful nonprofits typically pursue both strategies as complementary approaches to achieving their mission and ensuring long-term organizational health.
Like this tip? Check out my grant writing books, courses and newsletter.
Was this answer helpful? Share it now:
